You're probably aware that the best omni antenna, even with amps installed inline, won't do the job that a good directional antenna will do. If you're far enough away from your antennas, I won't suggest an omni.
But you probably have the same problem I have: install an antenna in your structured attic, where there is no room to swivel your antenna to get all your channels, thus a rotator will do you no good.
The next best thing is to determine where most of your stations are transmitting, and point an directional antenna that way. If you decide that there are two transmitters located 180 degs from each other at your location, you could try mounting two antennas and combining their signals at the mast, so you can get both of them.
Fortunately, my home is oriented is such a way that, when I installed our antenna, it's pointed directly between two strong transmitter locations about 45 degs apart. The lobes on my antenna catch both transmitters pretty well. However, the backside of my antenna has difficulty receiving the transmitter located directly behind our house. One of those things.
Wish I had a better suggestion. Good luck.