Question:
What T.V would you buy. LCD or Plasma?
sounds like a scam to me.
2009-03-14 14:21:21 UTC
I can't decide what to buy.

Sony LCD KDL52W4500 52 inch SCREEN

or the

Panasonic Plasma DMP-BD35EG-K 50 Inch screen

both are HD ready t.v's with similar spec's

I would really appreciate your views or comments on the above T.V's
Five answers:
Uncle Pennybags
2009-03-14 16:38:33 UTC
Each technology has certain pros and cons. You have to choose what's right for you.



LCD:

Lighter

Brighter - best for brightly lit rooms or rooms that have lots of natural light

More energy efficient

Poorer viewing angle - picture degrades as you move sideways away from the tv.

More expensive in larger sizes

Doesn't display dark scenes as well

Motion blur can be a problem, but not as bad as earlier generations

No burn in problems

More easily damaged screen



Plasma:

Heavier

Not as bright - less suitable for brightly lit rooms or rooms with lots of natural light.

Less energy efficient and runs hotter

Wide viewing angle

Less expensive in larger sizes

Displays dark scenes better

No motion blur

Subject to burn in, but not as bad as earlier generations

More durable screen



Many don't know it, but LCD screens are more subject to damage. My kid threw a pacifier at our brand new 52" LCD and knocked out a small group of pixels. Poke the screens in the store with your finger. You'll see what I mean.



Of the two you mention, both Panasonic and Sony make excellent TVs.
anonymous
2009-03-14 17:49:25 UTC
Try to read: Should I Buy a LCD TV or a Plasma TV? and

Full TV Specifications from

http://yefimsanswers.blogspot.com/2009/03/should-i-buy-lcd-tv-or-plasma-tv.html
jf
2009-03-14 14:53:43 UTC
Umm that Panasonic model number you gave is for a BluRay player not a TV. But overall picture quality I would go Panasonic Plasma (see below for the why).



LCD vs Plasma



LCD - is the everyman HDTV. It is cost effective, hence its popularity. It is also physically lighter than Plasma. It tends to draw less power than Plasmas as well (though good Plasmas are now beating LCDs). It has a matte finish so is useful for rooms that have too much ambient light which can not be controlled. LCD whites are a bit brighter than Plasma whites (but how often do you crank your brightness to 100%). LCDs are considered better for gaming (but I don't think you'd be disappointed with gaming on a modern Plasma). LCDs are sharper in SD (think evening news instead of film); this isn't a good vs bad, its just a personal preference thing.



It has problems with fast motion though. That is why you see ones advertised with 120Hz refresh rates. This does not come close to Plasma though. So they aren't as good for fast motion (sports and movies). The new 240Hz ones with LED backlighting are making good strides, but right now you're paying a HUGE premium for those features.



Plasma - they have better blacks, contrast, and motion blur. They are better TVs, but you often do have to pay a bit of premium for them. Images look smoother. They have greater ranges in blacks/whites so you get greys instead of clumps of black and white. The colors in Plasmas tend to have more "pop" to them; this isn't a good vs bad thing, its just personal preference. Plasmas are great for fast motion (sports and action movies).



Plasma's are glass though so are glossy. They can have reflection issues if you are in a room with lots of light that you can't control (you can't turn off the lights and you don't own any blinds). Also for SD viewing they are a bit "softer" (think more like film less like the evening news). This isn't a good vs bad thing, its personal preference. Most plasma owners get used to it and don't mind it.



They do have to be conditioned. The gasses of new Plasmas need to be conditioned. All you have to do is keep the brightness/contrast cranked way down for the first 100-200 hours, then optimize, and you'll have an amazing TV experience.



Plasma myth (1) - They experience burn-in. This is BS, those days are gone. Just condition the gasses and then use it as normal and you're fine. Also, the better sets have built-in features to prevent this (on top of the technology just generally being better now than say 5 years ago).



Plasma myth (2) - They have short life spans. This is more BS. You can leave your Plasma on 24/7 for 34 years before killing it. So do you think you'll still want/own the same TV in 15 years, let alone 30?



Plasma myth (3) - They won't work in high altitude because of problems for the gasses. This is again no longer an issue. Current Plasmas can be purchased and used in mile high Denver, and above, so you'll be fine where ever you are (unless you're living in the Himalayas).



Plasma vs LCD - One important note though is TV size. In 42" and above you see and get the benefit of the Plasma advantages. But 40" and smaller and the benefits are diminishing. So if you're going way smaller than LCD is likely the better option.



Plasma brands - Pioneer Kuro Elite is the best, followed by Pioneer Kuro. But these can cost as much as a small car. Panasonic Viera is the next best and is much more cost effective. Then I would go with Samsung. The Panasonic TH-50PZ800 or Samsung PN50A650 would both be top notch choices.



LCD brands - I would stick with Samsung, Sharp Aquos, and Sony (but only Sony if its on sale, otherwise it tends to be overpriced). Sony stopped manufacturing LCD panels, they now buy/use the same ones used in the Sharp Aquos sets. Samsung is a step above the rest if you go with the 5, 6, 7, or 9 series models.
cosiminijr
2016-12-17 11:39:50 UTC
this is extremely frightening in determining on and expertise all the innovations attainable. - Plasma TVs used to dominate over liquid crystal show by employing way of certainty they have been larger and had a extra efficient photograph. LCDs have caught up plenty and the two technologies are in a stable previous formed marketplace pushed wrestle. LED HDTVs are a sparkling breed yet very extreme priced. indoors the close to to destiny LED TVs may be as skinny as a credit card and ought to pass on a wall like wall paper. The technologies is extremely new and extreme priced. i does not propose getting an LED basically yet. pick for between a Plasma or liquid crystal show show show for now and wait until the cost drops and the technologies of LED HDTV evolves. - additionally, Plasma wins out indoors the evaluation ratio type. this is the version between the darkest darks and the whitest whites. The evaluation ratio of liquid crystal show video show gadgets has caught up yet although can not beat Plasma. - in case you would be utilising your television to view although photos or as a 2d computer show show (this is phenomenal with a Mac Mini by employing capacity of ways), liquid crystal show wins out. our flat show show computer video show instruments are liquid crystal show technologies by employing way of certainty they cope with although photos the surprising. - For shifting photos, like chase scenes in video clips, Plasma wins out. LCDs have caught up plenty yet there maintains to be a lag time that Plasma quite has an area over. Plasma TVs ought to be seen from very very just about the excellent factor. interior the journey that your room you would be putting the television in is small although, this could desire to not probable be counted. - the two Plasma and liquid crystal show have comparable lifetimes, the main considerable considerable factor relies upon on the producer. this is why you're waiting to desire to get HDTV scores for in spite of set you're desirous to purchase. do not base your judgement on huge type on my own, by employing way of certainty they could possibly be made up by employing capacity of the producer. - collectively because it includes capacity intake, liquid crystal show are although stunning, this is yet yet another reason they're used in computer video show instruments. this is employing the certainty the neon gas this is indoors a plasma television takes extra electric capacity to get rid of darkness from. The liquid crystal show TVs use some million/2 the capacity in many circumstances.etc.
Alberto
2009-03-14 15:07:23 UTC
LCD is better than plasma.

Plasma has a darker color

LCD looks brighter

if you go to a store where they have them turned on

and you compare the brightness of a plasma and LCD, LCD would win


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...